H 61° L 46°
Cloudy | 8MPH

Scott R. Gunther was longtime Shorewood coin dealer

Feb. 9, 2014

Scott R. Gunther, a history and literature buff, spent his entire adult life as a coin dealer.

For the past 40 years, Gunther either worked at or operated the Shorewood Coin Shop, a fixture on N. Oakland Ave. since its founding in 1974.

Like many kids, Gunther got the coin-collecting bug young, when he was about 7, after discovering a box of old coins hidden in a laundry chute in his grandfather's basement. Unlike most, Gunther made coins his profession.

Gunther died at age 63 last week, after a bout with lung cancer.

For the past 20 years, Gunther owned the Shorewood shop, buying and selling rare coins and jewelry but just as often simply talking politics or history with an extended community of friends.

His political views were on the far left, according to one of his daughters, Dream Gunther-Nettesheim. But her father wasn't one to push his views on anyone.

"He didn't try to shove his politics down anyone's throat," said Jeff Skaros, a longtime friend and former business partner at the coin shop. Gunther was good at putting customers at ease, Skaros said.

"There was no high pressure, no pushiness to him at all," Skaros said.

Gunther was patient and welcoming to people with limited social or intellectual skills, when they would come to the shop, said Keona Jacobs, another daughter of Gunther's. She got to see that side of her father while working with him one summer when she was in college, Jacobs said.

"He treated them special," she said.

Gunther was a Milwaukee native and Brown Deer High School graduate, who studied English literature for two years at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.

He maintained a lifelong interest in history and reading, a helpful background to his coin business, Gunther-Nettesheim said. He read history and fiction and loved Stephen King, she said.

With a low draft number and the Vietnam War raging, Gunther volunteered for service in the Army Reserve. That was a strategy that kept him stateside working as a cook, Gunther-Nettesheim said.

He used to joke about getting promoted and demoted seven times while in the service. On one occasion, Gunther barked at someone he glimpsed who had come into his kitchen without a hat on.

Gunther told him to "put your (expletive) hat on when you're in my (expletive) kitchen," Gunther-Nettesheim said, repeating a story she heard from her father. The visitor to the kitchen turned out to be a three-star general, and Gunther's wisecrack earned him one of his demotions, she said.

"He's not one who trusted authority easily," she said.

Skaros, who initially was Gunther's boss at the Shorewood shop, said Gunther was a steady presence from the earliest days — even when he wasn't being paid.

"There were times I couldn't afford to pay him, but he still showed up," Skaros said.

Gunther became well-versed in obscure coins and tokens, including Civil War tokens used in lieu of currency and bar tokens from the early 1900s, Skaros said.

His sense of whimsy was displayed by the names he chose for his twin daughters — Dream and Keona. Dream came from the classic Everly Brothers song, and Keona purportedly was an American Indian name meaning beautiful woman that he got from a movie, Gunther-Nettesheim said.

In addition to his two daughters, Gunther also is survived by five brothers, Rory, Kim, Lyn, Rick and Guy Gunther; and two grandchildren.

A memorial service starts at 7 p.m. Tuesday at Heritage Funeral Home Altstadt-Tyborski-Johnson-Reiss-Klemmer, 4800 S. 84th St. Visitation is from 5 to 7 p.m. at the funeral home.

View death notice and guest book

Suburban News Roundup

E-mail Newsletter

Your link to the biggest stories in the suburbs delivered Thursday mornings.

Enter your e-mail address above and click "Sign Up Now!" to begin receiving your e-mail newsletter
Get the Newsletter!

Login or Register to manage all your newsletter preferences.

Community Watch

» After 20 years, North Shore Fire Department celebrates efficiencies of consolidation 03:48 PM

» Services scheduled for Homestead High graduate killed in Afghanistan Updated:  01:39 PM

» Man charged with raping 15-year-old boy at gunpoint in Brown Deer 11:38 AM

» Homestead football ties for North Shore lead with win over Whitefish Bay 10/9

» Updated week eight rankings of area prep football teams and players 10/9

» Three North Shore cross country teams win major invitationals 10/9

» Flooded with Questions: North Shore suburbs five years after 2010 floods 10/8

» Shorewood/Messmer football team dominates Brown Deer upfront, 49-0 10/7

» Nicolet girls volleyball team rallies to win own Gigl tourney 10/7

» Homestead alum remembered after tragic plane crash 10/7

» Keeping an even strain: Nicolet girls win NSC tennis title 10/7

» Crave Bar & Food opens in Mequon 10/7

» Whitefish Bay football team controls its own NSC destiny this Friday 10/7

» SPORTS SHORTS: Oct. 8 10/7

» North Shore fire service consolidation saved millions, report says 10/6

» Brown Deer will build new public works building 10/5

» Milwaukee suburbs trick-or-treat times 2015 10/5

» Animated characters help patients discuss ailments, levels of pain 10/3

» Homestead High graduate killed in Afghanistan plane crash Updated:  10/2

» Badger Meter River Park opens in Brown Deer 10/2

» Glendale's 27th Street renamed to Sidney Place after homeowners' request Updated:  10/2

» Initial Reaction Podcast: Is Aaron Rodgers really the best QB in football? 10/1

» Kirkendoll saves day with pick as Whitefish Bay takes NSC grid lead 10/1

» Nicolet boys volleyball team holds off Homestead in NSC thriller 9/30

» Energized Shorewood swimmers just miss in Woodland meet 9/30

View All Posts Got a tip? Welcome rss




Local Business Directory


Most Popular