TEST - Debate continues to grow over right-of-way plantings

Plenty of viewpoints, but no resolution on controversial issue

Feb. 3, 2010

Shorewood — Forced into paying attention to a practice that has gone on for at least 80 years, the Village Board continues to struggle to find a solution to planting in public rights of ways.

Last spring, a Shorewood couple installed a raised planting box in the public right of way between sidewalk and street in the 4500 block of Newhall Avenue.

Someone complained and within 10 hours the couple, Naomi and David Cobb, were issued a citation. The Cobbs and others with plants in the rights of way then asked the village for a change in the ordinance to permit the plantings.

The Cobbs grew a vegetable crop in the bed during the summer. While the crops have long since been harvested, the issue sprouted by the box could linger into the beginning of another planting season.

No one wants that, and a village subcommittee met regularly to devise solutions. Right now, there is only one solution: Follow the current ordinance that does not allow any resident to plant in the rights of ways. However, the ordinance has been used on a complaint basis only and there are numerous other examples of plantings in the rights of way throughout the village.

New rules studied

The Village Board reviewed a second solution at its meeting on Monday. That solution, preferred by the committee studying the issue, would not allow planting boxes or structures in the rights of way, but would permit plantings 24 inches or shorter in at-grade beds.

That proposal contains setback requirements, requires residents to call Diggers Hotline and calls for a host of other restrictions, including filing an annual plan for right-of-way plantings with the village.

A complementary set of guidelines would clarify the use of pavers in the rights of way. They would continue to be permitted with a special privilege permit. Planting vegetation would require only filing a plan with the village, not the permit.

Village Attorney Ray Pollen said the community could face liability issues because of the new proposal, which is why residents who want to plant in the right of way would be required to show proof of liability insurance covering the village should anyone slip, trip or fall over private plantings in the right of way.

Residents weigh in

The proposal brought out both supporters and opposition at Monday's meeting.

Naomi Cobb, who said the issue is about sustainability, supported planting in the right of way, but wants to continue using a planting box. She did not support pavers.

"Allowing pavers is a mistake," she said. "That allows water to run off (onto the sidewalk or street).

Jerry Davis said he likes to garden, but not between the curb and sidewalk.

"There is a safety issue," he said, noting that he lives near St. Robert Church and school." I see people getting in and out of their cars. It is easy to trip on a plant. I don't support anything in an area where seniors and kids get dropped off."

John Reinhart noted that parking regulations prevent him from parking in front of his house on Wildwood Avenue, so he has to park across the street.

"If my neighbor chooses to plant in his right of way, I have to climb over whatever he puts there," he said.

Kay Wosewick, who spent the summer killing her lawn in order to replant with native plants, supported right-of-way planting and pavers. Wosewick said pavers should also be permitted along the edge of driveways, not just in the rights of ways.

Linda Drake pointed out that some of the plantings in the rights of way are very old. She lives in a house on Newhall Street built about 80 years ago.

"There was a builder who put a rose bush in the parkway after he completed every house," she said. The rose bush, about 4 feet tall, is fragrant and doesn't block the right of way, she said. "I think it would be a loss to have to cut down something like that."

Enforcement lacking

Michael Aita said the problem has arisen because the village has not enforced its existing ordinance.

"Around the corner from me, there is an eyesore in the right of way," he said. "I have complained about it, but nothing gets done."

He also raised a new issue.

In the end, with almost as many views as speakers, Village President Guy Johnson asked for two trustees to work with staff on a recommendation that would then go to the Buildings and Streets Committee for review and ultimately come back to the board for a vote.

This site uses Facebook comments to make it easier for you to contribute. If you see a comment you would like to flag for spam or abuse, click the "x" in the upper right of it. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use.

Suburban News Roundup

E-mail Newsletter

Your link to the biggest stories in the suburbs delivered Thursday mornings.

Enter your e-mail address above and click "Sign Up Now!" to begin receiving your e-mail newsletter
Get the Newsletter!

Login or Register to manage all your newsletter preferences.

Community Watch

» Homestead teacher is stepping down under deal Updated:  11/27

» River Lane Inn in Brown Deer sold to Pastiche owner Updated:  11/25

» Whitefish Bay Holiday Stroll coming on Friday 11/25

» Bomb squad examines grenade found in Brown Deer house 11/25

» Inspired by Popp, Homestead seizes fifth state football title 11/25

» Sport Shorts: Nov. 26, 2015 11/25

» Shorewood robbery suspects face charges 11/25

» River Lane Inn will become Pastiche 11/25

» Woodland champion Shorewood girls basketball team looks for third title 11/25

» Homestead girls basketball team has high expectations 11/25

» Highlanders rejoice over state football title 11/25

» Shorewood School District raises $1 million for STEAM programs 11/24

» Crews battle house fire in Brown Deer; 2 cats killed Updated:  11/23

» Cats, guinea pig die in fire 11/23

» Mequon woman reported missing 11/23

» Homestead wins fifth state football title, 28-12, over Waukesha West 11/20

» Build-your-own pizza place coming to Shorewood next year 11/20

» Shorewood families want to host Syrian refugees 11/20

» Updated state championship game rankings of area prep football teams and players 11/19

» Homestead football team faces uphill title fight against West 11/18

» Wolf and Zortman fill in each other's gaps well 11/18

» Apartments, assisted living pitched in Mequon development 11/18

» Mequon-Thiensville's Demond Means says MPS role won't interfere with his day job 11/18

» Hayes helps Brown Deer/USM swimming team set two program records 11/18

» Oak Leaf Trail extension links Milwaukee to Ozaukee County Updated:  11/18

View All Posts Got a tip? Welcome rss




Local Business Directory


Most Popular